Discord vs Slack: Which is the Best Platform to Grow Your Online Community?

Trish Decena

Trish Decena

Content Contributor, HeySummit

Published on 30th November 2023Updated 4th March 2024

In today's digital age, the art of fostering a robust and active online community hinges significantly on selecting the most suitable community platform. As virtual communities gain momentum, the debate of Discord Vs Slack - two of the frontrunners in online community platforms - becomes increasingly relevant.

These platforms are not merely tools for communication; they are the bedrock upon which vibrant online communities are built and nurtured. But the critical question is, which platform reigns supreme in facilitating the growth of an online community?

This blog post aims to unravel the unique features and functionalities of both Discord and Slack. We will meticulously compare these platforms to offer you a clear perspective on their capabilities in community building. Whether you're in the initial stages of creating an online community or contemplating a switch in platforms, this analysis will equip you with the knowledge to make an informed decision.

By the end of this post, you'll have a clearer understanding of which platform, between Discord and Slack, aligns best with the aspirations and dynamics of your online community.

Breaking Down the Core Features

Before diving into the core features of Discord and Slack, it's important to set the context for why choosing the right platform is critical for online community success. The digital landscape offers a plethora of tools, each with its unique strengths and functionalities

Discord: A Community-Centric Platform for Diverse Groups

Discord, originally popular among gamers, has evolved to cater to a wide array of communities. It is particularly favoured by groups seeking a casual, interactive space, such as hobbyists, fan clubs, and social groups. This platform is ideal for users who value real-time interaction and a vibrant community experience. Its extensive text, voice, and video channels facilitate dynamic communication, crucial for communities based on shared interests and activities.

Discord servers are a great way to connect to a group of people.

Discord's screen sharing, voice chat and file sharing capabilities, along with its event organisation tools, make it a top choice for community leaders looking to host immersive virtual events and foster a sense of belonging among members. The platform’s intuitive interface and customisation options further enhance its appeal to diverse communities seeking a user-friendly environment.

Slack: A Professional Collaboration Hub for Teams and Businesses

Slack, on the other hand, is tailored for professional use, particularly appealing to businesses, remote teams, and academic groups. It serves well for organisations that require structured communication and collaboration tools. Slack's advanced messaging, file sharing, and organisational tools make it a go-to choice for professional settings, including corporate teams, startups, and educational institutions.

Slack channels are offer efficient communication tools for community building and organising conversations.

The platform's focus on screen sharing, voice calls, and video calls caters to the needs of remote teams and business professionals who require reliable and efficient communication tools for their day-to-day operations. While Slack may not specialise in community-centric features like Discord, its design and functionality are perfectly suited for formal, team-based environments where streamlined communication and efficient collaboration are crucial.

The choice between Discord and Slack hinges on the specific nature and needs of your community. If you are aiming to build a community based on shared interests, hobbies, or casual interactions, Discord's community-oriented features and interactive environment offer the right setting. In contrast, if your focus is on fostering professional relationships, project management, and streamlined team communications, Slack stands out as the more suitable platform. Each platform serves distinct user groups, underscoring the importance of matching the platform's community features and capabilities with your community's needs and goals.

Creating a Strong Community Presence: User Experience on Discord and Slack

When it comes to building a strong community online, the user experience plays a vital role. Both Discord and Slack offer unique user experiences that contribute to the overall community presence. Discord's interface is visually appealing and intuitive, making it easy for users to navigate and engage with others. Its features such as voice and video channels foster real-time conversations, creating a sense of immediacy and connection. 

On the other hand, Slack's user experience is geared towards seamless team collaboration. Its threaded instant messaging system and file-sharing capabilities promote efficient communication and organisation within a team. While Discord excels in creating a dynamic and engaging environment for building a Discord community, Slack provides a professional and efficient platform for team-oriented communities or online community forums as an alternative to Facebook groups. Consider your community's needs and the desired user experience when deciding which platform is the best fit for creating a strong community presence.

Let's Talk Cost: Comparing Discord and Slack Pricing Models

When it comes to comparing Discord and Slack, the cost is an important factor to consider. Discord offers a free version that includes many essential features, making it an attractive option for those looking to start a Discord server community on a budget. 

However, it also offers a premium version called Discord Nitro, which provides additional benefits such key features such as enhanced audio and video quality, custom emojis, and larger file upload limits.

On the other hand, Slack offers a tiered pricing structure that starts with a free version, but with limited features and storage space. To access more advanced features and functionality, such as unlimited message history and integration with other apps, you'll need to upgrade your free plan to a paid plan. Slack's paid plans vary in price depending on the number of users and additional features required.

Ultimately, when comparing the pricing models of Discord and Slack, it's important to consider the specific needs of your community. If you're just starting out or have a limited budget, Discord's free version may be the more cost-effective choice. However, if you require advanced features and have a larger team or more specific needs, Slack's paid plans may offer better value for your Slack community. Take the time to evaluate your requirements and choose the option that aligns best with your budget and community goals.

Essential Integrations: Evaluating Essential Integrations and Extensibility

When it comes to building an online community, having the right integrations and extensibility options can greatly enhance your community's functionality and engagement. Both Discord and Slack offer a range of integrations that can be easily integrated into your community, allowing you to streamline workflows and provide additional value to your members.

From project management tools like Trello and Asana, to communication tools like Zoom and Google Meet, these integrations can help you create a seamless and efficient experience for your community members. Additionally, both platforms have extensive APIs and developer tools, giving you the ability to customise and extend the platform to meet your community's unique needs. 

Whether you're looking to start a Discord community or a Slack community, evaluating the available integrations and extensibility options is crucial in ensuring that your community has the tools it needs to thrive. So, take the time to explore the integration possibilities of each platform and choose the one that aligns best with your community's goals and needs.

Understanding Security Measures and Privacy Policies

When it comes to building an online community, security and privacy are essential considerations. Discord and Slack both have robust security measures in place to protect your community members and their data. Discord uses end-to-end encryption for all communication, ensuring that messages and files are secure. 

Additionally, they have implemented measures to prevent spam and harassment, such as the ability to block users and enable two-factor authentication. Slack also prioritises security, offering features like single sign-on and data encryption. They also have granular control settings to manage access and permissions within your community. 

Both platforms have privacy policies in place to protect user information and comply with data protection regulations. Understanding these security measures and privacy policies is crucial in choosing the right platform for your community and ensuring the safety of your members.

Drawbacks and Limitations

While both Discord and Slack have many advantages for community building, it's important to acknowledge their drawbacks and limitations. One potential drawback of Discord is that its interface can be overwhelming for new users who are unfamiliar with gaming platforms. The abundance of features and customisation options may require a learning curve for some community members. Additionally, Discord's focus on voice channels and real-time communication may not be suitable for communities that primarily rely on written conversations.

On the other hand, Slack's pricing structure can be a limitation for smaller communities or those on a tight budget. While the free version of Slack offers limited features, accessing more advanced functionalities requires upgrading to a paid plan. This cost can add up, especially for larger communities or those with specific integration needs.

Picking the Right Platform: Aligning Your Community's Needs with the Suitable Tool

The journey to elevate your online community begins with a crucial choice: selecting the right community platform. Whether you’re steering a dynamic membership community or aiming to enhance community engagement, the decision between Discord and Slack is pivotal. Each platform offers unique features, from integrating third-party tools to fostering unique member experiences.

Now is the time to assess your community’s core needs. Do you prioritize seamless communication, robust file sharing, and the ability to integrate a variety of third-party tools? Or is your focus on creating an exclusive membership community with tailored interactions and content? Consider the aspects that are most critical to your community's success and choose a platform that aligns with these priorities.

Evaluate, decide, and adopt the right community platform that will transform your vision into a thriving online community. The choice you make today will shape the future of your community's engagement and growth.

Recent Posts

Ready to Take the Stage with HeySummit?

Try for free. No credit card required.

Ready to Take the Stage with HeySummit?